Breed comparison
Alaskan Malamute
vs Great Pyrenees.
Both are large, thick-coated working breeds bred to operate independently of constant human direction, the Malamute to haul freight across the snow, the Great Pyrenees to guard flocks alone on a mountainside at night. Both are famously strong-willed, and neither is a natural obedience-competition dog.
The core difference is energy: the Malamute is a very-high-energy athlete that needs to move, while the Great Pyrenees is a low-energy, nocturnal-minded guardian that is happiest patrolling calmly, not running.
Quick answer
Choose the Alaskan Malamute if you want an athletic, high-energy working partner and can meet its serious exercise needs. Choose the Great Pyrenees if you want a calmer guardian presence and can live with its natural barking and independent protective instincts. Both are large, strong-willed breeds that need experienced handling and thorough socialization, not casual first dogs.
Alaskan Malamute
- Trainability
- 6/10
- Energy
- Very high
- Training difficulty
- 77/100
- Group
- Working
Great Pyrenees
- Trainability
- 6/10
- Energy
- Low
- Training difficulty
- 47/100
- Group
- Working
Scores from the TailorPup Dog Training Difficulty Index.
Key differences
Energy
The Alaskan Malamute is very-high energy, a powerful sled dog that needs serious daily exercise or it becomes destructive. The Great Pyrenees is low energy by comparison, a guardian breed built for calm, watchful patrolling rather than exertion, often most active at night.
Trainability
Both score 6/10 and both are independent thinkers bred to make their own decisions on the job, not to take constant direction. The Malamute channels this into pulling, digging, and escaping; the Great Pyrenees channels it into deciding for itself whether a person, animal, or noise is actually a threat.
Barking
The Great Pyrenees is a famous, deep, often nighttime barker, its job is to alert and deter from a distance, and this instinct is very difficult to train away entirely. The Malamute is vocal too, prone to howling, but barks less as a guarding behavior and more from excitement or protest.
Role and instinct
The Malamute is a pack-oriented sled dog with a strong prey drive toward small animals. The Great Pyrenees is a livestock guardian bred to bond with and protect a flock or family independently, which can translate into territorial protectiveness of home and family without formal guard training.
Which is easier to train?
Both score 6/10, and both are intelligent breeds that simply were not bred to prioritize a handler input over their own judgment, the Malamute because it had to make split-second sled decisions, the Great Pyrenees because it had to guard alone all night without supervision. Reward-based, patient, consistent training builds a working relationship with either, but full off-leash reliability is unrealistic for both. Early socialization matters enormously for the Pyrenees guarding instinct and the Malamute prey drive alike.
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Alaskan Malamute
Very active owners who want a powerful, athletic sled-type companion and can provide serious daily exercise, secure fencing, and patient management of digging and escaping.
Alaskan Malamute training guide →Choose the Great Pyrenees
Owners who want a calmer, low-energy guardian presence and can manage a strong, near-untrainable nighttime barking instinct and independent protective judgment.
Great Pyrenees training guide →The verdict
Choose the Alaskan Malamute if you want an athletic, high-energy working partner and can meet its serious exercise needs. Choose the Great Pyrenees if you want a calmer guardian presence and can live with its natural barking and independent protective instincts. Both are large, strong-willed breeds that need experienced handling and thorough socialization, not casual first dogs.
Frequently asked questions
Which is calmer, a Malamute or a Great Pyrenees?
The Great Pyrenees is far calmer day to day, it is a low-energy guardian breed built for watchful patrolling rather than exertion. The Alaskan Malamute is very-high energy and needs serious daily exercise to stay settled.
Which barks more?
The Great Pyrenees, clearly. Its role as a livestock guardian built in a strong, often nighttime barking instinct used to alert and deter from a distance, which is very difficult to train away. The Malamute is vocal too, more through howling than guard barking.
Are either easy to train?
Neither is easy in the obedience-school sense; both score 6/10 as independent working breeds bred to think for themselves. Both respond best to patient, consistent, reward-based training rather than an expectation of quick, precise obedience.
Whichever you pick, train it right
TailorPup builds a personalized 12-week program around your dog's exact breed, age, and behavior, no generic one-size plan.
Build my dog's programMore: all breed comparisons · training difficulty index · all 240 breed guides