The American Water Spaniel is a versatile, all-round hunting spaniel from the upper Midwest, eager and capable in water and field, but more independent-minded and occasionally stubborn than the easygoing retrievers it resembles. Most training problems come from underestimating the hunt drive or running into the independent streak. Here are the five mistakes that cause the most trouble, and what to do instead.
1. Under-exercising
This is a genuine working spaniel that needs 60 to 90 minutes of vigorous daily activity, and an unexercised one redirects its energy into barking, chewing, and restlessness. Owners who treat it as a calm house dog are quickly caught out. Provide real exercise, swimming, retrieving, and a job for its nose, and the same dog settles happily indoors, since this is a breed that genuinely switches off once its body and nose have had a proper workout.
2. Going off-leash before recall is solid
The American Water Spaniel's hunt drive is powerful, and a dog that catches scent or sees birds will override a half-built recall and range off. Owners who trust open ground too soon teach the dog that recall is optional. Build a rock-solid recall on a long line with high-value rewards first, and treat reliable off-leash freedom as something earned over months.
3. Insufficient socialization
The breed tends to be reserved with strangers, and without thorough early socialization that reserve hardens into wariness. Owners who under-expose the puppy end up with a suspicious adult. Socialize broadly and positively during the puppy window so the natural reserve stays polite rather than fearful.
4. Harsh handling
The American Water Spaniel responds to patient, reward-based work and shuts down or grows resistant under harsh corrections. Owners who apply pressure get a less willing dog. Use reward-based methods, keep sessions upbeat and varied, and the breed's eagerness to work with you comes through.
5. Ignoring the independent streak
Some lines carry a real stubborn streak, and an owner who expects automatic obedience and gives up when met with resistance never builds reliability. Stay consistent, follow through every time, and pay competitive rewards; the breed cooperates well when the work is worthwhile and consistent.
What works with American Water Spaniels
Exercise the dog well, build recall before trusting the hunt drive off-leash, socialize early, train with rewards, and stay consistent with the independent streak. What ties these together is channeling an independent all-rounder: the AWS has real hunt drive and a stubborn side, so a job, vigorous exercise, patient recall, and competitive rewards keep it cooperative. Variety suits it especially well, and early socialization softens its natural reserve into a confident, versatile companion.
TailorPup's American Water Spaniel plan channels the breed's hunting drive, builds recall carefully, and manages its independence.
Start your American Water Spaniel's plan free at tailorpup.com →
Related: How to Train an American Water Spaniel · Recall Training · Leash Pulling · Puppy Training Basics